Brierlie Walters

Brierlie Walters

Brierlie Walters was a 39-year-old mother of three living in Oil City, Pennsylvania with her live-in boyfriend, Brandon Richard Wells.

On the afternoon of May 5, 2022, Oil City Police were dispatched to the home they shared at 12 Mineral Street in Oil City for the report of a deceased woman. When the first officer arrived, he was met in the doorway by Wells who warned the officer that "this is going to look suspicious."

The officer entered the dilapidated house, walked upstairs, and found a blue stainless steel drum positioned at the foot of the bed in the main bedroom. The officer lifted the towel covering the barrel's opening and found Walters, deceased, naked, and facing downward.

Wells was arrested and charged with criminal homicide and other drug-related and child endangerment crimes. The trial took place in August of 2023. He was found guilty on all counts.

Date:

Saturday, March 5, 2022

Crime:

Homicide

Location:

Oil City, PA, USA

Age:

39

Photos of Brierlie Walters

Photos of Brandon Richard Wells

Case Documents

Image

Landlord Tennant Complaint

September 28, 2021
Image

Criminal Complaint

March 6, 2022
Image

Order Granting Motion for Hearing

September 19, 2022
Image

Order of Court

October 19, 2022
Image

Order of Court

January 9, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Additional Discovery

January 11, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Discovery – In Camera Review – Notice to Opposing Counsel

January 19, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Additional Discovery – Notice to Opposing Counsel

January 31, 2023
Image

Commonwealth’s Notice

February 6, 2023
Image

Memorandum for the Preservation of Evidence

February 6, 2023
Image

Order Granting Motion to Compel Discovery

February 13, 2023
Image

Order of Court – In Camera Review (CYS)

February 13, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Additional Discovery

February 24, 2023
Image

Order of Court

March 13, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Additional Discovery

June 13, 2023
Image

Motion to Compel Additional Discovery

July 6, 2023
Image

Order of Court

July 7, 2023
Image

Motion for Pre-Trial Discovery

July 20, 2023
Image

Response to Commonwealth Motion for Pre-Trial Discovery

July 20, 2023
Image

Pre-Trial Motions

July 26, 2023
Image

Commonwealth Response to Defendant Pre-Trial Motions

July 26, 2023
Image

Motion in Limine

August 3, 2023
Image

Motion in Limine

August 3, 2023

Trial Notes

I attended the trial of Brandon Richard Wells in my capacity as a reporter for a local Western Pennsylvania publication. These are my handwritten notes that I took each day of the trial. You'll notice that my handwriting is poor and I made a lot of grammar and spelling mistakes. But if you want the whole story of what happened at trial, this is where you'll find it.
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Jury Selection Day

August 7, 2023
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Trial Day 1

August 8, 2023
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Trial Day 2

August 9, 2023
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Trial Day 3

August 10, 2023
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Trial Day 4

August 11, 2023
Image

Brandon Wells Trial – Trial Day 5 (Verdict)

August 14, 2023