By Gavin Fish, March 23, 2024
Philadelphia’s recent motion to delay depositions in the Ellen Greenberg case has sparked further frustration among her family and supporters, who allege a cover-up of her 2011 death. The Greenbergs continue their decade-long fight for justice, contesting the controversial suicide ruling.
If you are struggling with suicidal thoughts or are experiencing a mental health crisis, help is available. Call the 24/7 National Suicide & Crisis hotline at 988 or 1-800-273-8255, or go to 988Lifeline.org.
The case of Ellen Greenberg, a 27-year-old first grade teacher found dead in her Philadelphia apartment in 2011, continues to face significant delays, infuriating her family and supporters. Ellen, who was found with 20 stab wounds, had her death controversially ruled a suicide by the Philadelphia medical examiner, Dr. Marlin Osborne. This ruling has been heavily contested by Ellen’s parents, Josh and Sandy Greenberg, who allege a cover-up.
Recently, a motion filed by the city of Philadelphia has stalled the deposition process, further delaying the case. This motion seeks to stay discovery and depositions until the court rules on preliminary objections, including claims of high public official immunity for the medical examiners involved. The Greenbergs’ legal team, led by Joe Pedroza and Will Trask, had been preparing to depose Guy D’Andrea, a former assistant district attorney who discovered Ellen’s case file hidden in a closet.
Despite a judge previously allowing the Greenbergs to proceed with discovery, the new motion by Philadelphia aims to halt these efforts, citing undue burden on the defendants. This has been a common strategy, with the city using procedural tactics to prolong the case and exhaust the Greenberg family’s resources. The legal process has already spanned over a decade, with significant legal expenses borne by the family.
The Greenbergs’ lawsuit alleges a conspiracy to cover up Ellen’s murder, involving various city officials and departments. They argue that the initial ruling of suicide is inconsistent with the evidence, which includes defensive wounds and signs of a violent struggle. The family’s fight for justice has garnered widespread support, with many advocating for the case to be reopened and thoroughly investigated.
As the court continues to delay decisions on preliminary objections, the community remains in support of the Greenbergs, urging for a fair and transparent legal process. The next steps in this case are critical, with the potential to finally bring clarity and justice for Ellen Greenberg and her family.
